Puzzler wrote:McAz wrote:Puzzler wrote:wutang wrote:Avon Barksdale wrote:Incidentally, whether this terrorist had a mental illness or not is not particularly relevant unless it completely diminishes his capacity to make decisions / takes away human agency (which is unlikely.)
It's like mental illness is used as a convenient excuse or justification for actions which cannot be excused or justified. This type of intellectually lazy thinking spans the political spectrum.
Didnt Brevik try playing that card and the courts threw it out.
The other problematic thing with the whole 'lets downplay white terrorism with mental illness' thing is that it stigmatises and demonises people with mental illness - millions of people suffer from some form but you dont see them committing terror acts.
Then again the media love demonising mental illness as well so it two birds with one stone for them.
Ah yes I remember well, Richard Dart and Samantha Lewthwaite's actions being explained away as a result of mental illness.
By whom?
That's my point - they weren't therefore not all white terrorists are classed as mentally ill. Wutang is just desperate for this to be a race issue when there could just as easily been a white muslim or 2 in the crowd of victims last night.
I've not heard of any terrorist escaping justice because of mental illness - white, black or anything else - but it is something young Vipes peddled earlier in this thread which is why there was the usual responses.